A HubForge MEL book · Curated by Shashidhar S A

Giants of Evidence

The lives and big ideas that built monitoring, evaluation and learning

Every tool in your MEL kit was once somebody's answer to a hard question. One question runs through all of them: how would we know?

  • 24giants
  • 67big ideas
  • 5acts
  • 5great debates
  • 24templates

Where do you want to start?

Ralph W. TylerObjectives-based evaluation (the Tyler rationale)
Open story
  • Methods, rigour and causality
  • Value and judgement
  • Use and learning
  • Theory and programme logic
  • Participation, equity and voice
  • Made in the Global South
  • Impact evaluation and evidence systems

Tiles are coloured by each person's main family of ideas. Some show portraits adapted from openly licensed photographs; the others are original HubForge emblems, not likenesses.

Keep this volume

Read the edition in your browser, or save the PDF.

The complete, 606-page international B5 edition. Open it in a new tab to read with your browser’s built-in PDF viewer.

02 · Why people

Why learn MEL through people?

Most of us meet evaluation as a set of finished tools: a logframe template, a theory of change workshop, a sampling formula, a story collection form. They arrive without their history, so they can feel arbitrary, and we use them mechanically.

Every one of those tools began as somebody's answer to a real problem. An evaluator needed to show whether experimental schools still prepared students for college. A field worker in Bangladesh needed to summarise progress without a fixed list of indicators. Economists working with an Indian NGO wanted to know whether a remedial tutoring programme actually helped children learn. When you know the problem behind a tool, you know when to use it, when to bend it and when to put it down.

People also make ideas memorable. It is easier to recall a person's turning point than a definition, and easier to argue with a thinker than with a box on a form. This book uses 24 stories to help you hold the field in your head as a living conversation, with disagreements, rather than a list of methods.

Who this book is for

New to MEL

Students, fellows, programme staff moving into M&E, first-job analysts.

Start with the families of ideas and the timeline to see the shape of the field. Then read Tyler, Scriven, Weiss, Patton, Chambers and Davies and Dart. Use the glossary freely, and try one template per week on whatever you are working on.

Practising consultant or MEL lead

Evaluators, MEL managers and consultants who design and deliver studies.

Go straight to the problem crosswalk near the end. Find the problem on your desk this week, read the two or three figures it points to, and use their templates in your inception report. Use the limits sections to anticipate pushback.

Leading evaluation functions and ecosystems

Heads of evaluation, commissioners, funders, network builders and teachers of evaluation.

Read the profiles of institution builders: Stufflebeam, Rist, White, Rogers, Segone, Ofir, Chilisa and Zaveri. Notice how ideas spread through centres, handbooks, training schools and networks. Use the career lessons and reflection questions with your team.

NextThe five actsHow the field grew, from the 1930s to today

03 · Five acts

How the field was built

The 24 giants in the order their work took hold, in five acts from the 1930s to today. Open any act to read its story and key dates, or tap a giant to read theirs.

Act 1 of 5 · 1930s to 1960s

What Did They Learn? Measuring What Matters

In the early 1930s, testing in American schools largely meant checking whether pupils had memorised content, and secondary schools were tightly bound to college entrance requirements. When the Eight-Year Study freed around thirty schools to experiment, Ralph Tyler faced a problem no standard test could solve: each school had its own purposes. His answer, from 1934, was to start from those purposes, define what each would look like in students' work, and build a range of instruments to gather evidence on them. He set out the logic in 1949 in Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction, and is widely credited with bringing the word evaluation into the vocabulary of schooling.

Read the whole act and its key dates

In the early 1930s, testing in American schools largely meant checking whether pupils had memorised content, and secondary schools were tightly bound to college entrance requirements. When the Eight-Year Study freed around thirty schools to experiment, Ralph Tyler faced a problem no standard test could solve: each school had its own purposes. His answer, from 1934, was to start from those purposes, define what each would look like in students' work, and build a range of instruments to gather evidence on them. He set out the logic in 1949 in Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction, and is widely credited with bringing the word evaluation into the vocabulary of schooling.

His research assistant in 1938, Lee Cronbach, went on to transform measurement itself, with coefficient alpha in 1951 and construct validity, with Paul Meehl, in 1955. In 1963 Cronbach turned back to evaluation and argued that it does most good while a course is still being developed, feeding improvement, rather than only judging a finished product. By the mid 1960s new federal funding was producing ambitious curriculum reforms, yet evaluations often reported little beyond average test scores. In 1967 two answers appeared. Michael Scriven named formative and summative evaluation and argued, against Cronbach, that judging overall worth mattered as much as supporting improvement. Robert Stake argued that a full evaluation must both describe and judge, comparing what was intended with what was observed. In 1972 Scriven went further still, proposing that evaluators could set stated goals aside and search for all of a programme's effects.

In our reading, this first act moves from a single question, did pupils reach the objectives, to a harder one: were these the right objectives, and what else happened along the way? Every logframe and every results framework in use today still lives inside that tension.

  1. 1934Ralph Tyler becomes director of evaluation for the Eight-Year Study.
  2. 1949Tyler publishes Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction.
  3. 1951Cronbach publishes Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of Tests.
  4. 1963Cronbach publishes Course Improvement through Evaluation.
  5. 1967Scriven names formative and summative evaluation; Stake publishes The Countenance of Educational Evaluation.
  6. 1972Scriven publishes Pros and Cons About Goal-Free Evaluation.

Act 2 of 5 · 1960s to 1990s

The Experimenting Society

In the 1960s evaluation left the classroom and entered government. The Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 brought federal money to American schools, and an amendment demanded by Senator Robert Kennedy required evaluation of its Title I programmes. Local educators were often unprepared, and that demand, the Encyclopedia of Evaluation records, helped drive the development of many evaluation models. The tools to hand had been built for testing pupils, not for judging whole policies.

Read the whole act and its key dates

In the 1960s evaluation left the classroom and entered government. The Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 brought federal money to American schools, and an amendment demanded by Senator Robert Kennedy required evaluation of its Title I programmes. Local educators were often unprepared, and that demand, the Encyclopedia of Evaluation records, helped drive the development of many evaluation models. The tools to hand had been built for testing pupils, not for judging whole policies.

Donald Campbell supplied a discipline for judging causes in the field. In 1963, with Julian Stanley, he catalogued sixteen designs and listed eight threats to internal validity and four to external validity. In 1969, in Reforms as Experiments, he turned the toolkit on public policy, showing how a Connecticut claim about a speeding crackdown ignored trends and ordinary year-to-year swings. Daniel Stufflebeam, a test developer suddenly advising on federal evaluation, built the CIPP model, first presented in Austin in 1966, which treated evaluation as a service to decisions at every stage of a programme's life. Carol Weiss, whose 1972 textbook was among the first in the field, asked why findings seemed to be ignored, and in 1979 described seven ways research enters policy, including the slow enlightenment of debate. Huey-tsyh Chen, working with Peter Rossi, argued in 1983 that experiments treated programmes as black boxes, and in 1990 set out theory-driven evaluation.

In 1991 Shadish, Cook and Leviton grouped Campbell with Scriven as theorists who sought to bring truth to social problem solving, and Weiss with Stake and Joseph Wholey as theorists who emphasised use and pragmatism. In our reading, this act answered the first by scaling up its ambition: from whether pupils learned to whether a society could learn from its own reforms.

  1. 1963Campbell and Stanley publish Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research.
  2. 1965The Elementary and Secondary Education Act requires evaluation of Title I programmes.
  3. 1966Stufflebeam presents the emerging CIPP model in Austin, Texas.
  4. 1969Campbell publishes Reforms as Experiments.
  5. 1972Weiss publishes Evaluation Research.
  6. 1990Chen publishes Theory-Driven Evaluations.

Act 3 of 5 · 1970s to 2010s

Will Anyone Use It? The Use Revolution

By the 1970s programme evaluation had grown quickly in the United States, and an uncomfortable question had become pressing: did any of it change decisions? Michael Quinn Patton treated this as a research problem. A 1977 field study by Patton and colleagues interviewed about 60 project officers, decision-makers and evaluators linked to 20 health programme evaluations, and pointed to what he called the personal factor: findings were most likely to be used when an identifiable person cared about the evaluation and what it would find. In 1978 the first edition of Utilization-Focused Evaluation argued that an evaluation should be judged by its actual use. In 1994 he introduced the term developmental evaluation for work alongside innovations still taking shape.

Read the whole act and its key dates

By the 1970s programme evaluation had grown quickly in the United States, and an uncomfortable question had become pressing: did any of it change decisions? Michael Quinn Patton treated this as a research problem. A 1977 field study by Patton and colleagues interviewed about 60 project officers, decision-makers and evaluators linked to 20 health programme evaluations, and pointed to what he called the personal factor: findings were most likely to be used when an identifiable person cared about the evaluation and what it would find. In 1978 the first edition of Utilization-Focused Evaluation argued that an evaluation should be judged by its actual use. In 1994 he introduced the term developmental evaluation for work alongside innovations still taking shape.

Others carried the idea inside organisations and into complexity. In 1999 Hallie Preskill and Rosalie Torres described evaluative inquiry, in which an organisation's own members continually examine what they do as part of daily work. Sanjeev Sridharan and colleagues proposed in 2006 that stakeholders set out when a programme should first be expected to show impact, and in 2011 he and Nakaima set out ten steps to make evaluation matter, arguing that a programme's complexity should shape its evaluation's design. Patricia Rogers, introduced to program logic at an evaluation conference in Canberra in 1987, argued in 2008 that evaluators should classify aspects of an intervention as simple, complicated or complex, and in 2011, with Sue Funnell, presented programme theory as a family of tools chosen to fit purpose.

In Alkin and Christie's evaluation theory tree, Stufflebeam, Patton and Preskill sit on the use branch. In our reading, this act answered the experimenting society with a practical rejoinder: a rigorous finding that no one acts on has helped no one, so the evaluator's craft must include the people and organisations who will use what is learned.

  1. 1978Patton publishes the first edition of Utilization-Focused Evaluation.
  2. 1994Patton introduces the term developmental evaluation in Evaluation Practice.
  3. 1999Preskill and Torres publish Evaluative Inquiry for Learning in Organizations.
  4. 2006Sridharan, Campbell and Zinzow propose the stakeholder-driven anticipated timeline of impact.
  5. 2008Rogers publishes on using programme theory for complicated and complex interventions.
  6. 2011Funnell and Rogers publish Purposeful Program Theory; Sridharan and Nakaima publish Ten steps to making evaluation matter.

Act 4 of 5 · 1970s to 2010s

Many Voices, Many Truths

From the 1970s, the Encyclopedia of Evaluation records, evaluators fought what they themselves described as their most bitter debate, between quantitative and qualitative ways of knowing. It was methodological and philosophical, but also political, because it touched who defines good evidence. Judged by the conventional tests of validity and objectivity, a study built on interviews in one setting looked soft. In 1985, in Naturalistic Inquiry, Yvonna Lincoln and Egon Guba argued that such work rests on different assumptions and should be judged by its own criteria of trustworthiness; in 1989 Fourth Generation Evaluation organised a whole approach around negotiation among stakeholders. The same year N. L. Gage wrote about the paradigm wars in research on teaching, and Jennifer Greene, Valerie Caracelli and Wendy Graham reviewed 57 mixed-method evaluations to set out five purposes for combining methods.

Read the whole act and its key dates

From the 1970s, the Encyclopedia of Evaluation records, evaluators fought what they themselves described as their most bitter debate, between quantitative and qualitative ways of knowing. It was methodological and philosophical, but also political, because it touched who defines good evidence. Judged by the conventional tests of validity and objectivity, a study built on interviews in one setting looked soft. In 1985, in Naturalistic Inquiry, Yvonna Lincoln and Egon Guba argued that such work rests on different assumptions and should be judged by its own criteria of trustworthiness; in 1989 Fourth Generation Evaluation organised a whole approach around negotiation among stakeholders. The same year N. L. Gage wrote about the paradigm wars in research on teaching, and Jennifer Greene, Valerie Caracelli and Wendy Graham reviewed 57 mixed-method evaluations to set out five purposes for combining methods.

Far from American campuses, a parallel challenge was growing. Robert Chambers showed in 1983 how short official visits to villages were biased towards roadsides, better off people and the dry season, and in 1994 he documented participatory rural appraisal, in which rural people map and analyse their own realities while the outsider facilitates. In Bangladesh in 1994 the Christian Commission for Development in Bangladesh first used the technique Rick Davies designed, which Jess Dart later trialled in Australia and which became Most Significant Change: a way to collect stories of change and choose openly among them. In 1998 Donna Mertens led the American Evaluation Association under the theme of transforming society through evaluation, and went on to build a transformative paradigm that starts from power and justice.

In our reading, this act answered the use revolution by asking whose use, and whose truth. It widened the field's circle of legitimate knowers, from experts to participants, and made the evaluator's own values part of the question.

  1. 1983Chambers publishes Rural Development: Putting the Last First.
  2. 1985Lincoln and Guba publish Naturalistic Inquiry.
  3. 1989Greene, Caracelli and Graham publish their framework for mixed-method evaluation designs; Guba and Lincoln publish Fourth Generation Evaluation.
  4. 1994Chambers publishes on participatory rural appraisal in World Development; CCDB first uses Davies's technique in Rajshahi, Bangladesh.
  5. 1998Mertens serves as AEA president with the theme Transforming Society Through Evaluation.
  6. 2005Davies and Dart publish The Most Significant Change (MSC) Technique: A Guide to Its Use.

Act 5 of 5 · 1990s to 2020s

Evidence for a World in a Hurry

At the turn of the millennium, governments in developing countries faced growing pressure to show results, from the Millennium Development Goals adopted in 2000 to poverty reduction strategies and aid conditions. Most public monitoring still checked spending and activities, not outcomes. Ray Rist and Jody Zall Kusek answered in 2004 with Ten Steps to a Results-Based Monitoring and Evaluation System, which began by asking whether anyone in government actually demanded the information; IPDET, which Rist co-founded with Linda Morra Imas, had been training evaluators since 2001. In 2003 Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo and Sendhil Mullainathan founded what became J-PAL, bringing randomised field experiments to questions such as remedial tutoring with Pratham in Vadodara and Mumbai. In 2008 3ie was founded, with Howard White as its first executive director, and in 2009 he argued that impact studies must trace the causal chain, not just report an average.

Read the whole act and its key dates

At the turn of the millennium, governments in developing countries faced growing pressure to show results, from the Millennium Development Goals adopted in 2000 to poverty reduction strategies and aid conditions. Most public monitoring still checked spending and activities, not outcomes. Ray Rist and Jody Zall Kusek answered in 2004 with Ten Steps to a Results-Based Monitoring and Evaluation System, which began by asking whether anyone in government actually demanded the information; IPDET, which Rist co-founded with Linda Morra Imas, had been training evaluators since 2001. In 2003 Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo and Sendhil Mullainathan founded what became J-PAL, bringing randomised field experiments to questions such as remedial tutoring with Pratham in Vadodara and Mumbai. In 2008 3ie was founded, with Howard White as its first executive director, and in 2009 he argued that impact studies must trace the causal chain, not just report an average.

The rush to rigour provoked a second movement. In January 2007, at the African Evaluation Association conference in Niamey, Zenda Ofir and Sulley Gariba led the session Making Evaluation Our Own, prompted in part by their judgement that imported trial designs did not reflect African ways of knowing. Bagele Chilisa gave the idea theory, from her 2012 Indigenous Research Methodologies to the 2015 synthesis paper on Made in Africa Evaluation. Marco Segone helped launch EvalPartners in 2012 to strengthen national evaluation associations, and in December 2014 the UN General Assembly adopted a resolution on country-level evaluation capacity. In South Asia, Sonal Zaveri helped found the Community of Evaluators in 2008 and later led a real-time, gender-focused evaluation during the COVID-19 response.

In 2012 Fred Carden and Marvin Alkin observed that evaluation theory from low and middle income countries seemed to have collective, practice-based origins rather than individual authors. In our reading, this act moves the field's centre of gravity to where programmes happen, and asks that evidence be both rigorous and owned.

  1. 2001IPDET, co-founded by Rist and Linda Morra Imas, is first delivered.
  2. 2003Banerjee, Duflo and Mullainathan found what becomes J-PAL.
  3. 2007The Making Evaluation Our Own session is held at the fourth AfrEA conference in Niamey, Niger.
  4. 20083ie is founded, with White as its first executive director; the Community of Evaluators South Asia is formed.
  5. 2012EvalPartners is launched; Chilisa publishes Indigenous Research Methodologies.
  6. 2019Banerjee, Duflo and Michael Kremer receive the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.
NextFamilies of ideasSeven traditions that organise the field

04 · Families of ideas

Seven families of ideas

Every giant belongs mainly to one family and often borrows from a second. Choose a family to filter the 24 stories.

3 lead · 2 related

Methods, rigour and causality

How do we know a claim is true? Designs, measures and quality criteria that make evidence trustworthy, from field experiments to qualitative inquiry.

3 lead · 1 related

Value and judgement

Evaluation means judging worth: whose values count, which criteria apply and how to reach a defensible verdict.

4 lead · 5 related

Use and learning

Evaluation that people actually use, built around decisions, intended users, complexity and organisational learning.

4 lead · 1 related

Theory and programme logic

Making a programme's purposes and assumptions explicit, from stated objectives to theories of change, and then testing them.

3 lead · 5 related

Participation, equity and voice

Putting the people a programme serves at the centre of who asks the questions and whose reality counts.

3 lead · 2 related

Made in the Global South

Evaluation grounded in African, South Asian and other Global South knowledge, values, networks and leadership.

4 lead · 4 related

Impact evaluation and evidence systems

Counterfactuals, evidence synthesis, results-based systems and the national and global infrastructure of evaluation.

Full tile: main familyFaded tile: second family

NextTimeline1930s to 2020s, and what comes next

05 · Timeline

Nine decades of answers

From one evaluation director in the 1930s to a global field. Choose a decade, swipe or scroll along the line, and open any milestone to meet the person behind it.

Milestones 1 to 4 of 26
NextThe 24 storiesSearch, filter and open any giant

06 · Gallery

The 24 stories

Roughly in order of when each person's work took hold. Each opens as a long-form biography: the life, the breakthrough, the big ideas and the debates, then a section that puts the ideas to work.

Showing all 24
NextThe great debatesFive arguments that shaped the field

07 · Great debates

Five arguments that shaped the field

Evaluation grew through argument. Each debate sets out both sides fairly, says what happened, and asks where you stand.

Great debate 1 of 5 · Act 2

Proof Here or Promise Elsewhere?

Should evaluation first prove that a programme caused an effect, or show whether the effect will travel?

See both sides and what happened

Side A

Internal validity first (Campbell)

Campbell's starting point was that a claim of programme success means little if rival explanations have not been ruled out. In 1963, with Julian Stanley, he catalogued sixteen designs and eight threats to internal validity, giving field researchers a shared language for what a comparison could and could not prove. In 1969, in Reforms as Experiments, he urged governments to treat reforms as experiments, and showed how a governor's claim about a speeding crackdown ignored trends and ordinary year-to-year swings. The Encyclopedia of Evaluation records that Campbell continued to prioritise internal validity. In our reading, his case is simple and powerful: before asking whether a result will transfer, be sure the result is real.

Side B

External validity and many studies (Cronbach)

Cronbach argued that the question policymakers most need answered is whether a programme that succeeded in one place will succeed in another, with different people and conditions. In Designing Evaluations of Educational and Social Programs (1982) he set out his units, treatments, observations and settings framework to address exactly that. According to the Encyclopedia of Evaluation, he opposed relying on one large experiment, which he likened to a horse race, and favoured many smaller studies, each looking closely at an important case or component. He saw evaluation as political and its main audience as a wide policy-shaping community. In our reading, his case is that a clean answer to a narrow question can still mislead a busy decision-maker.

What happened

Neither side simply won. In 1991 Shadish, Cook and Leviton placed Campbell among the stage one theorists who sought to bring truth to social problem solving, and Cronbach among the stage three theorists who tried to integrate what came before. In Evaluation Roots (2004), Thomas Cook wrote a chapter on how both men shaped his own theory of causal generalisation. Chen, who had criticised black box experiments with Peter Rossi in 1983, proposed in 2010 a bottom-up approach to integrative validity. In our reading, the same argument resurfaced in development economics after 2010, when critics asked whether trial results transfer across settings.

Where you stand

  1. Think of a pilot in your organisation that showed good results. What would you need to know before recommending it for a different district or state?
  2. If you had budget for one large study or five small ones, which would you choose for your next evaluation, and why?

Great debate 2 of 5 · Act 1

Goals or No Goals?

Should a programme be judged against its own stated objectives, or against everything it actually does?

See both sides and what happened

Side A

Start from objectives (Tyler)

Tyler's approach began with purposes. In the Eight-Year Study, rather than impose one standard test on very different schools, he and his staff worked from each school's own stated aims, clarified what each would look like in students' work, and built varied instruments to gather evidence on them. He distilled this into the 1949 Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction. The strength of the approach is fairness and clarity: a programme is held to what it set out to do, in terms its own staff understand, and evidence is gathered on more than test scores. In our reading, every results framework that asks a programme to define its intended outcomes and then measure them descends from this logic.

Side B

Look for all effects (Scriven, with Stake)

Critics argued that judging a programme only against its own objectives can miss unintended effects and cannot say whether the objectives were worth pursuing. In Pros and Cons About Goal-Free Evaluation (1972), Scriven drew on the way consumer product testers judge goods without asking manufacturers what they intended, and proposed that evaluators set stated goals aside and search for all of a programme's effects. Robert Stake, from a different angle, argued in 1967 that a full evaluation must both describe and judge, comparing intentions with what was actually observed, and later developed responsive evaluation around the issues people at a site care about. In our reading, their shared case is that goals can become blinkers.

What happened

Goal-free evaluation never became the norm. Brandon Youker, who has written extensively on the approach, reports that most evaluators treat it as a rhetorical reminder rather than a workable design, partly because strict blinding to goals is hard to achieve. Yet its central worry spread. In Christie's account of the second edition of the theory tree, goal-free evaluation sits on the objectivist side of the valuing branch, and Stake's responsive evaluation underlies most theories on the subjectivist side. Most Significant Change was designed partly because predefined indicators risked missing the unexpected. Tyler did not formally reply to his critics.

Where you stand

  1. In your last evaluation, what was the most important effect that nobody had written into the logframe?
  2. Could you design one part of your next evaluation in which the field team is not told the programme's objectives? What would you gain and lose?

Great debate 3 of 5 · Act 3

Use or Judgement?

Is an evaluation's first duty to be used by the people who need it, or to deliver an independent verdict on worth?

See both sides and what happened

Side A

Judge evaluation by its use (Patton)

Patton built his approach on evidence. A 1977 field study by Patton and colleagues found that findings were most likely to be used when an identifiable person cared about the evaluation, which he called the personal factor. Utilization-Focused Evaluation (1978) argued that evaluations should therefore be judged by their actual use and organised around specific primary intended users and their intended uses. In a 1996 issue of Evaluation Practice he argued that the world of evaluation was larger than the formative and summative distinction, pointing to developmental and knowledge-generating work. In our reading, his case is that an evaluation nobody uses is a cost without a benefit, however rigorous it is.

Side B

Evaluation means judging merit and worth (Scriven)

Scriven saw evaluation as the determination of value, and held that a competent evaluator can establish a programme's worth as a matter of fact rather than as a matter of taste. It was Scriven who in 1967 named formative and summative evaluation and insisted that judging overall worth was as important as supporting improvement. In the same 1996 issue of Evaluation Practice, he replied to Patton and others by defending the formative and summative distinction as one reasonable way to classify evaluation. A recurring concern in the field is that a focus on primary intended users can tilt an evaluation towards what powerful users want to know.

What happened

Both positions became pillars of the field. In Alkin and Christie's evaluation theory tree, Patton's work sits on the use branch and Scriven's at the base of the valuing branch, and the 2023 third edition of Evaluation Roots still gives both their own chapters. Patton went on to develop developmental evaluation, whose early adopters, in Mark Cabaj's 2011 study, wrestled with exactly this tension: whether to judge, and to whom they are accountable. Weiss's earlier work had already shown that use itself takes many forms, from direct application to slow enlightenment.

Where you stand

  1. Who are the primary intended users of the evaluation you are working on now, and have you asked them what they will do with the findings?
  2. When a funder and a community want different things from an evaluation, whose question comes first for you?

Great debate 4 of 5 · Act 4

The Paradigm Wars

Do qualitative and quantitative evaluation rest on incompatible views of reality, or can they be combined?

See both sides and what happened

Side A

A different paradigm with its own criteria (Guba and Lincoln)

Guba, a statistician who had worked inside the measurement tradition, came to doubt that conventional approaches could answer evaluation questions well. In Naturalistic Inquiry (1985) he and Lincoln argued that the naturalistic paradigm rests on different assumptions from conventional science, so studies within it should be judged by parallel criteria of trustworthiness rather than by internal and external validity. In 1986 they added criteria of authenticity, and in 1989 Fourth Generation Evaluation built an approach around negotiation among stakeholders. They advised against mixing positivist and constructivist propositions in a single study, while insisting that relativism did not mean anything goes. In our reading, their case is that methods carry worldviews.

Side B

The experimental tradition replies

Critics from the experimental tradition questioned whether a relativist position could yield findings that decision-makers could rely on, and whether parallel criteria could carry the weight of validity. William Shadish argued in 1995 that few evaluation theorists or practising evaluators were in fact logical positivists, a movement he described as largely dead in philosophy by the late 1940s, and that method choice often does not follow directly from philosophy. He also argued that experiments can include qualitative observation. Campbell himself, in Shadish's account, had written in support of qualitative work. In our reading, their case is that the war was fought partly against a caricature.

What happened

The field moved towards combination rather than conquest. In 1989 Greene, Caracelli and Graham reviewed 57 mixed-method evaluations and named five purposes for mixing methods. In 1997 Greene and Caracelli described purist, pragmatic and dialectic stances, the last treating tensions between paradigms as a source of fuller understanding. Mertens later built her transformative paradigm on the four philosophical assumptions Guba and Lincoln had identified. Shadish took Denzin and Lincoln's 1994 Handbook of Qualitative Research as a sign that qualitative methods had become established. The argument over paradigms continues in quieter form.

Where you stand

  1. In your current work, do numbers and stories answer different questions, or are they used to confirm each other? Which of Greene's purposes are you really serving?
  2. Is there a finding you trust from interviews that you could not defend to a sceptical statistician? How would you make your case?

Great debate 5 of 5 · Act 5

The Randomistas and Their Critics

Are randomised trials the best route to knowing what works against poverty, or one tool among many?

See both sides and what happened

Side A

Break big questions into testable ones (Banerjee and Duflo)

The Nobel committee's 2019 account summarised the approach: break the large question of global poverty into smaller, precise questions, such as which interventions best improve schooling or child health, and answer them through carefully designed experiments among the people most affected. In their 2009 review of the experimental approach, Banerjee and Duflo argued that its main advantage is close collaboration between researchers and implementers, which allows questions to be tested that could not otherwise be evaluated. They took the criticisms seriously but concluded that many were not specific to experiments. In his Nobel lecture Banerjee argued that replication across sites, combined with theory, can support generalisation.

Side B

No special access to truth (Deaton, Stern, Ofir)

Angus Deaton argued in the Journal of Economic Literature in 2010 that randomised trials and quasi-experiments give no special access to credible knowledge, that they often fail to handle heterogeneous effects, and that evaluating projects without understanding mechanisms is unlikely to advance knowledge of development. With Nancy Cartwright he later argued that results strictly describe the trial sample and that trials should be combined with other methods and theory. A 2012 DFID working paper led by Elliot Stern concluded that experimental designs suit only a minority of programmes. In Africa, Zenda Ofir and Sulley Gariba judged that such designs did not reflect African ways of knowing and could oversimplify complex communal societies.

What happened

Both camps reshaped practice. Banerjee, Duflo and Michael Kremer received the 2019 Nobel prize, and the committee credited one of their Indian studies with leading to remedial tutoring that has benefited more than five million children. Deaton himself welcomed a shift in development experiments from project evaluation towards testing mechanisms. Howard White argued in 2009 that impact evaluations should trace the full causal chain, and the Stern paper pressed for a broader range of designs. Ofir's concern helped spark Made in Africa Evaluation, which Chilisa developed into theory. The debate continues.

Where you stand

  1. For the programme you know best, what is the one question a randomised trial could answer well, and the one it could not?
  2. If a trial found an average effect of zero, what would you want to know about who gained and who lost before you advised ending the programme?
NextThe family treeWho shaped whom

08 · Family tree

Who shaped whom

Adapted from the evaluation theory tree of Alkin and Christie. Lanes are branches; positions run from the 1930s on the left to the 2020s on the right.

METHODSUSEVALUINGSOCIALJUSTICECONTEXT ANDNEEDS(PROPOSED)1930s1940s1950s1960s1970s1980s1990s2000s2010s2020sRTTylerDCCampbellLCCronbachCWWeissRossiHCChenMSScrivenRSStakeG&LGuba and LincolnJGGreeneDSStufflebeamMPPattonHPPreskillAlkinDMMertensRCChambersSZZaveriMSSegoneD&DDavies and DartPRRogersSSSridharanRRRistD&BDuflo and BanerjeeDeatonHWWhiteZOOfirBCChilisa
InfluencedChallengedExtendedScroll sideways on a phone

How to read it. Each edge reads as a sentence: from, type, to. For example, cronbach challenged campbell; tyler influenced cronbach; chilisa extended Alkin.

Methods

Theories that emphasise research design, causal inference and generalisation. One of the three original branches of Alkin and Christie's evaluation theory tree; Christie (2024) describes Campbell's work as foundational to it. A position on a branch shows relative emphasis, not exclusive focus (Mark 2024).

Use

Theories that emphasise how evaluation serves decisions, intended users and organisational learning. An original branch of the tree; in the 2004 book its part includes Stufflebeam, Wholey, Patton, Alkin, Fetterman, Cousins, King, Preskill and Owen.

Valuing

Theories that emphasise how evaluators reach judgements of merit and worth. An original branch; in the second edition it was split into an objectivist side, rooted in Scriven, and a subjectivist side, rooted in Stake (Christie 2024).

Social justice

A fourth branch added by Donna Mertens, aligned with the transformative paradigm (Mertens and Wilson 2012). Mark (2024) notes that Alkin and Christie's most recent version instead places more of these theories on the valuing branch. We use it here for evaluators who put power, equity and participation first.

Context and needs (proposed fifth branch)

A proposed branch, not part of Alkin and Christie's tree. Mertens (2023) proposed a fifth branch named context and needs, fitting an Indigenous paradigm. Chilisa (2024) describes the case for it, made in her own work and with Mertens, as drawing on the culture, philosophy, history and experience of formerly colonised peoples in Africa and Indigenous peoples elsewhere. Earlier, Chilisa and colleagues (2016) proposed an African relational evaluation paradigm and an African evaluation tree.

Method note. This family tree is our adaptation of a published framework, the evaluation theory tree of Marvin Alkin and Christina Christie, introduced in Evaluation Roots (2004) and revised in later editions (a second edition, then a third in 2023, which classifies theories rather than theorists). Placements marked as Alkin and Christie's are inferred from the part of Evaluation Roots in which a theorist's chapter appears (Methods, Valuing or Use), as listed by SAGE for the 2004 book, or from the 2023 Guilford contents for Greene, Chen and Preskill; the tree's own diagram was not consulted directly, so leaf positions within a branch are not reproduced. The social justice branch is Mertens's revision, not Alkin and Christie's. The context and needs branch is a proposal by Mertens and Chilisa, not an accepted part of the tree. All placements of Chambers, Davies and Dart, Rogers, Sridharan, Rist, Duflo and Banerjee, White, Ofir, Chilisa, Segone, Zaveri and Deaton are ours, as are era years, which mark a defining publication or event in each figure's profile. Edges summarise sourced relationships; where a note says our reading, the connection is interpretive. Patton himself has suggested a river metaphor and found the tree too constrained (Christie 2024), and Mertens (2024) notes that a tree does not show interrelationships between paradigms: read this as one map among several.

NextI have this problemMatch the problem on your desk to a giant

09 · Problem crosswalk

I have this problem

Pick the problem on your desk this week. You get the idea to borrow and the two or three giants to read first.

NextWrite your own storyA worksheet you can download

10 · Worksheet

Write your own story

Every person in this book started with a problem they could not leave alone. Use these prompts to write the first page of your own evaluation story. Come back to it in a year.

Your answers stay in this browser only.

NextGlossaryKey terms in plain words

11 · Glossary

Key terms in plain words

20 terms you will meet in the stories, from counterfactual to transformative paradigm.

20 terms
Change model and action model
In theory-driven evaluation, the change model describes how an intervention produces outcomes; the action model describes how the programme must be delivered to make that happen.
CIPP model
Context, Input, Process, Product: four linked evaluation questions designed to serve decisions throughout a programme.
Coefficient alpha
A statistic estimating how consistently a set of survey or test items measures something. It is a lower bound on reliability and does not prove a scale measures a single thing.
Counterfactual
What would have happened without the programme. Impact evaluations estimate it, often with a comparison or control group.
Developmental evaluation
Evaluation that works alongside innovators in complex, changing situations, giving real-time feedback to support adaptation.
Evidence gap map
A visual summary of where evidence on a set of interventions and outcomes exists and where it is missing.
Formative evaluation
Evaluation done to improve something while it is being developed or delivered.
Goal-free evaluation
Judging what a programme actually does against the needs of those it serves, without being steered by its stated goals.
Made in Africa Evaluation
The call for evaluation in Africa to be grounded in African philosophies, contexts and values and led by African evaluators.
Most Significant Change (MSC)
A participatory monitoring technique in which stories of change are collected and then discussed and selected at different levels, revealing what stakeholders value.
Participatory rural appraisal (PRA)
A family of visual, group-based methods, such as mapping, transect walks and wealth ranking, through which local people produce and analyse their own information.
Quasi-experimental design
A design that compares groups or time periods without random assignment, while ruling out rival explanations as far as possible.
Randomised evaluation
An impact design in which chance, such as a lottery, decides who receives a programme, so differences in outcomes can be credited to it.
Responsive evaluation
Evaluation organised around the concerns and issues of people connected with a programme, often using case study, and reported in forms they can use.
Summative evaluation
Evaluation that judges the overall worth of something, usually to inform a decision about it.
Theory of change
An explicit account of how and why a programme's activities are expected to lead to its intended outcomes, including the assumptions behind each step.
Threats to validity
Rival explanations or weaknesses that could make a causal claim, or its generalisation, wrong.
Transformative paradigm
A framework that centres people facing discrimination or oppression, attends to power and designs research and evaluation to support social justice.
Trustworthiness
In naturalistic inquiry, the set of criteria used to judge the quality of qualitative work in place of conventional validity and reliability.
Utilization-focused evaluation
An approach that judges evaluations by whether intended users actually use them, and designs everything around those users and uses.
NextMethod and sourcesHow every fact was checked

12 · Method

An honest note on method

How the book was curated, how every fact was checked, how AI was used, and what the book is and is not.

Facts checked as of October 2026

Why we made this book

Every tool in your MEL kit was once somebody's answer to a hard question. We curated this book to celebrate the people who asked those questions first, to make their big ideas clear enough for anyone to use, and to inspire a new generation to join the work. Behind it sits one purpose: a stronger evaluation ecosystem, of practitioners, students, commissioners, governments and communities, using evidence well to help build a fairer and better world.

Who made it

The book was curated by Shashidhar S A, founder of HubForge Global, and is published by HubForge Global Impact Network Foundation. The curator chose the 24 figures, set the brief for every chapter, directed the writing and design through many rounds of revision, and reviewed and approved the final text. The choices of who to include, what to emphasise and how to tell each story are ours, and so is the responsibility for them.

How we chose the 24

We chose the 24 to show how the field grew, not to rank anyone. We looked for people whose ideas changed everyday practice, across different eras, regions, methods and roles, from university theorists to field practitioners and movement builders, with a deliberate place for voices from Africa and South Asia. Many others shaped the field, and we hope future editions will tell more of their stories.

Where the facts come from

Each profile was built from a research fact sheet compiled from public sources: university and institutional pages, publishers' author pages, professional association records such as the American Evaluation Association's award lists, encyclopaedia entries, obituaries and the person's own published work. More than 300 of these sources are listed in Notes and sources, from <a class="pref" data-ref="notes" data-fmt="p">p. 000</a>, as a starting point for your own reading rather than a complete bibliography. Where sources disagreed on a date or detail, we left it out or hedged it, for example by writing around 1990 or the mid-1960s. Where a fact rested on one weak source, or could not be confirmed, we left it out.

How we used AI

We used artificial intelligence openly in making this book. AI tools helped us to search and summarise public sources, draft and edit the text, check consistency and lay out the pages, always under the curator's direction. We did not let AI supply facts of its own: every fact in the book is meant to trace back to a listed public source. We ran automated checks that every number, date and name in the rewritten chapters already appeared in the sourced research, followed by a separate fact-checking pass that corrected errors and removed claims the sources did not support. AI can still make mistakes, and so can people, which is why we invite corrections.

How we tell the stories

The storytelling is ours. Chapter openings, passages that invite you to imagine a situation, the Picture it comparisons, the Your moves cards, the worked examples, templates, AI prompts and reflection questions are HubForge's own writing and interpretation. They are not claims about what any person said, believes or would recommend. Worked examples are invented for teaching unless a source is named. We did not invent scenes, dialogue, thoughts or feelings, and we deliberately avoided direct quotations, because quotations are often misremembered, trimmed or lifted out of context. Instead, we describe each person's ideas in our own words and point you to their original work.

Portraits and emblems

Five figures are shown by portraits adapted from openly licensed photographs: cropped, traced into vector shapes and recoloured, and credited in Picture credits, from <a class="pref" data-ref="credits" data-fmt="p">p. 000</a>. Every other figure is shown by an original HubForge emblem that stands for their big idea. The emblems are not likenesses.

Respect for the people

We have not stated whether a person is living unless that was clearly confirmed, we have kept current job titles to a minimum, and we have kept to each person's public professional record. Criticisms are summaries of published debate, offered in good faith for learning, not personal judgements. Inclusion in this book is not an endorsement by the people profiled, their families or their institutions.

Corrections and limits

Facts were checked against public sources as of October 2026. If you spot an error, an omission or an outdated detail, or if you are a person profiled and want something corrected, write to hubforgeglobal@gmail.com and we will review it promptly and fix the next edition. This book is for learning and inspiration, not professional advice; please read the Legal notices, from <a class="pref" data-ref="legal" data-fmt="p">p. 000</a>, before relying on it.

NextNotes and sourcesEvery source, by giant, and picture credits

13 · Notes

Notes and sources

Every source behind the 24 stories, numbered by giant. Follow a link to read the original, or open the story it supports.

Chapter 01 · 15 sources

Ralph W. Tyler

  1. Obituary of Ralph W. TylerStanford University News Service · 1994
  2. Tyler, Ralph W. (1902 to 1994)Encyclopedia of Education, via Encyclopedia.com
  3. Ralph W. Tyler Papers, finding aid and biographical noteUniversity of Chicago Library, Special Collections Research Center
  4. Eight-Year StudyEducation Encyclopedia, StateUniversity.com
  5. History of NAEP, The Nation's Report CardNational Center for Education Statistics
  6. Books of the Century (Craig Kridel)Educational Leadership, ASCD · 2000
  7. Basic Principles of Curriculum and InstructionEncyclopedia of Curriculum Studies, SAGE · 2010
  8. Lee J. Cronbach 1916 to 2001, Biographical Memoir (Richard J. Shavelson)National Academy of Sciences · 2009
  9. Objectives-Based EvaluationEncyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE (ed. Sandra Mathison) · 2005
  10. Tyler, Ralph W.Encyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE (ed. Sandra Mathison) · 2005
  11. Understanding the Tyler rationale: Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction in historical context (William G. Wraga)Espacio, Tiempo y Educacion 4(2) · 2017
  12. Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction, with a foreword by Peter S. Hlebowitsh (publisher listing)University of Chicago Press · 2013
  13. An Interview with Ralph Tyler (Jeri Ridings Nowakowski, interview of November 1981)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 7(15) · 2011
  14. Educational Objectives: The Blueprint for Instruction and Evaluation (George F. Madaus)The Irish Journal of Education 1(1), via Educational Research Centre · 1967
  15. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 02 · 10 sources

Lee J. Cronbach

  1. Lee J. Cronbach 1916 to 2001, Biographical Memoir (Richard J. Shavelson)National Academy of Sciences · 2009
  2. Lee J. Cronbach (1916 to 2001), obituary (Richard J. Shavelson and Goldine Gleser)American Psychologist, 57(5) · 2002
  3. Cronbach, Lee J(oseph) 1916 to 2001Contemporary Authors, via Encyclopedia.com
  4. Cronbach, Lee J.Encyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE (ed. Sandra Mathison) · 2005
  5. Course Improvement through EvaluationTeachers College Record, 64(8) · 1963
  6. Center for Instructional Research and Curriculum EvaluationEncyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE · 2005
  7. Construct Validity in Psychological Tests (Cronbach and Meehl), Psychological Bulletin 52, 281 to 302Classics in the History of Psychology, York University · 1955
  8. Invited discussion of Cronbach (1951) Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests (Klaas Sijtsma)Psychometrika, via Tilburg University Research Portal · 2016
  9. Coefficients and Indices in Generalizability Theory (Robert L. Brennan), CASMA Research Report 1University of Iowa · 2003
  10. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 03 · 17 sources

Michael Scriven

  1. Even So, Too Soon: Michael John Scriven (28 March 1928 to 28 August 2023), by Gene V. GlassJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 20(47) · 2024
  2. Scriven's Goal-Free Evaluation, by Brandon W. YoukerJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 20(47) · 2024
  3. Revisiting and Expanding Scriven's Fallacies About Formative and Summative Evaluation, by Janet Clinton and John HattieJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 20(47) · 2024
  4. Michael Scriven and The Missing Half of Quantitative Evaluation, by Brian Yates and Nadini PersaudJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 20(47) · 2024
  5. In memoriam: AERA Past President Michael ScrivenAmerican Educational Research Association · 2023
  6. Remembering Michael ScrivenClaremont Graduate University · 2023
  7. Honoring the legacy of Michael ScrivenInternational Evaluation Academy · 2023
  8. Michael Scriven (1928 to 2023)European Evaluation Society · 2023
  9. In memoriam: Michael Scriven (1928 to 2023)Leiter Reports · 2023
  10. Obituary report on Michael ScrivenPoint Reyes Light · 2023
  11. Goal-free evaluation, by Brandon W. YoukerSAGE Encyclopedia of Educational Research, Measurement, and Evaluation · 2018
  12. Past award winnersAmerican Evaluation Association
  13. The Logic and Methodology of Checklists, by Michael Scriven (revised December 2007)The Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University, via MandE NEWS · 2007
  14. The Unruly Logic of Evaluation, by Michael ScrivenStudies in Critical Thinking, Oklahoma State University Open Textbooks
  15. Goal-Free Evaluation in Theory and Practice (Evaluation Cafe slides), by Brandon W. YoukerThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University · 2017
  16. Formative, Preformative, and Proformative Evaluation, by Michael ScrivenJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 8(18) · 2012
  17. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 04 · 14 sources

Robert E. Stake

  1. Stake, Robert E.Encyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE (ed. Sandra Mathison) · 2005
  2. Countenance Model of EvaluationEncyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE · 2005
  3. Responsive Evaluation (Tineke A. Abma)The SAGE Encyclopedia of Educational Research, Measurement, and Evaluation · 2018
  4. Center for Instructional Research and Curriculum EvaluationEncyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE · 2005
  5. Intrinsic Case StudyEncyclopedia of Case Study Research, SAGE · 2010
  6. Standards-Based and Responsive Evaluation (publisher listing and author biography)SAGE Publications, via Woodslane · 2004
  7. Honors item on Robert Stake's honorary doctorate from the University of ValladolidInside Illinois, University of Illinois News Bureau · 2009
  8. Program Evaluation, Particularly Responsive Evaluation (in Evaluation Models, eds Stufflebeam, Madaus and Kellaghan)Kluwer Academic Publishers, via Illinois Experts · 2002
  9. A Guide to Responsive EvaluationCanadian Institute for Substance Use Research, University of Victoria
  10. Program Evaluation, Particularly Responsive Evaluation (Robert E. Stake, 1973 address; CIRCE Occasional Paper 5)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 7(15) · 2011
  11. The Art of Case Study Research (publisher listing)Sage Publications, via Bookshop.org · 1995
  12. Multiple Case Study Analysis (publisher listing)Guilford Press · 2005
  13. Instrumental Case StudyEncyclopedia of Case Study Research, SAGE · 2010
  14. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 05 · 11 sources

Donald T. Campbell

  1. Donald T. Campbell: Social Psychologist and Scholar, 1916 to 1996APS Observer, Association for Psychological Science · 1996
  2. Donald T. Campbell memorialLehigh University Libraries
  3. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research (Campbell and Stanley)Houghton Mifflin; originally in N. L. Gage (ed.), Handbook of Research on Teaching, Rand McNally · 1963
  4. Reforms as ExperimentsAmerican Psychologist · 1969
  5. Methods for the Experimenting SocietyPrepared for 1971 presentations; revised version in E. S. Overman (ed.), Methodology and Epistemology for Social Science, University of Chicago Press, 1988
  6. Assessing the Impact of Planned Social ChangePublic Affairs Center, Dartmouth College, Occasional Paper 8 (reprinted in Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation, 2011) · 1976
  7. Modern Regression Discontinuity Analysis (Howard S. Bloom)MDRC · 2009
  8. Collaboration links real life to research on what worksPenn Today, University of Pennsylvania · 2000
  9. International Development Coordinating Group3ie
  10. Cronbach, Lee J.Encyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE (ed. Sandra Mathison) · 2005
  11. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 06 · 15 sources

Daniel L. Stufflebeam

  1. Remembering Daniel L. StufflebeamThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University · 2017
  2. The parent of evaluation: Daniel Stufflebeam, 1936 to 2017Social Science Space · 2017
  3. Daniel Stufflebeam obituaryLangeland Family Funeral Homes · 2017
  4. Founders: Ohio StateThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University
  5. FoundersThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University
  6. Standards of Excellence from a Leader of Excellence, by Michael Quinn PattonJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 13(29) · 2017
  7. Program evaluation standardsSAGE Encyclopedia of Evaluation · 2005
  8. Educational Evaluation and Decision Making (catalogue record)Texas A&M University Libraries · 1971
  9. Evaluation Models: New Directions for Evaluation 89AbeBooks listing of the Jossey-Bass volume · 2001
  10. About the evaluation checklistsThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University
  11. The Application of the CIPP Evaluation Model in Educational Programs in IndonesiaScaffolding: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam dan Multikulturalisme · 2025
  12. Programme Evaluation of B.Ed. English at a Remote Higher Education Institution in Nepal Using CIPP ModelKMC Journal · 2026
  13. CIPP Evaluation Model Checklist, by Daniel L. StufflebeamBetterEvaluation (listing of the Evaluation Center checklist) · 2007
  14. guilford.comWeb page
  15. eval.orgWeb page
Chapter 07 · 10 sources

Carol H. Weiss

  1. HGSE remembers Professor Carol WeissHarvard Graduate School of Education · 2013
  2. Carol Weiss obituaryBoston Globe via Legacy.com · 2013
  3. Weiss, Carol HirschonSAGE Encyclopedia of Evaluation · 2005
  4. Interview with Carol H. Weiss, by Karen HorschThe Evaluation Exchange, Harvard Family Research Project · 1998
  5. The Many Meanings of Research Utilization (summary)AcaWiki
  6. TOC originsCenter for Theory of Change
  7. AEA365 post on Carol Weiss and theory-based evaluationAmerican Evaluation Association
  8. Chapter on Weiss's Evaluation Research, by Kathryn NewcomerThe Oxford Handbook of Classics in Public Policy and Administration · 2015
  9. Past award winnersAmerican Evaluation Association
  10. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 08 · 16 sources

Huey-tsyh Chen

  1. Huey Chen biographyMercer University College of Health Professions
  2. Huey T. (Tsyh) Chen author pageSAGE Publishing
  3. Chen, Huey-Tsyh (Encyclopedia of Evaluation entry)SAGE Knowledge · 2005
  4. The Multi-Goal, Theory-Driven Approach to Evaluation (Social Forces 59:1)Oxford Academic · 1980
  5. Evaluating With SenseIDEAS/RePEc (Evaluation Review) · 1983
  6. Development of a National Evaluation System to Evaluate CDC-Funded Health Department HIV Prevention ProgramsAmerican Journal of Evaluation · 2001
  7. Review of Practical Program EvaluationCDC, Preventing Chronic Disease · 2006
  8. The bottom-up approach to integrative validityIDEAS/RePEc (Evaluation and Program Planning) · 2010
  9. Evaluation Practice vol. 15 no. 1 contentsKB National Library of the Netherlands · 1994
  10. The Baggaging of Theory-Based Evaluation (Davidson)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation · 2006
  11. Using Theory to Improve Program and Policy EvaluationsBank Square Books (Praeger listing) · 1992
  12. Past Award WinnersAmerican Evaluation Association
  13. Theory-Driven Evaluations (book page and table of contents)SAGE Publishing · 1990
  14. Theory-driven evaluation (Encyclopedia of Evaluation entry)SAGE Knowledge · 2005
  15. Practical Program Evaluation: Foundations of the Field and Current Advancements, third editionSAGE College Publishing · 2026
  16. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 09 · 20 sources

Michael Quinn Patton

  1. Patton, Michael Quinn (Encyclopedia of Evaluation entry)SAGE Knowledge · 2005
  2. Our TeamUtilization-Focused Evaluation
  3. Why Blue Marble Evaluation?Utilization-Focused Evaluation
  4. Blue Marble Evaluation: Premises and PrinciplesRoutledge (Guilford Press title) · 2019
  5. Current Empirical Research on Evaluation Utilization (Cousins and Leithwood)Review of Educational Research, via Western Michigan University · 1986
  6. Facilitating Evaluation, chapter 4 (sample chapter)SAGE · 2018
  7. The Dr. Seuss Approach to EvaluationHarvard Family Research Project, The Evaluation Exchange · 1994 talk
  8. Developmental Evaluation: The Experience and Reflections of Early Adopters (Cabaj)University of Waterloo · 2011
  9. Utilization focused evaluation: a primer for evaluatorsIDRC Digital Library · 2013
  10. American Journal of Evaluation, vol. 17 no. 2 contentsSAGE Journals · 1996
  11. Blue Marble Evaluation webinarCECAN · 2021
  12. Past Award Winners; Annual Conference HistoryAmerican Evaluation Association
  13. Essentials of Utilization-Focused Evaluation: checklist chapterSAGE · 2011
  14. Essentials of Utilization-Focused Evaluation (product page)SAGE College Publishing · 2011
  15. Utilization-focused evaluation: the new century text (third edition, catalogue record)BRAC University Library · 1997
  16. Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and UseGuilford Press · 2010
  17. Developmental Evaluation Exemplars: Principles in PracticeGuilford Press · 2015
  18. Using developmental evaluation to enhance continuous reflection, learning and adaptation (table of DE principles)Health Research Policy and Systems, BioMed Central · 2020
  19. guilford.comWeb page
  20. eval.orgWeb page
Chapter 10 · 17 sources

Hallie Preskill

  1. Preskill, Hallie (Encyclopedia of Evaluation entry)SAGE Knowledge
  2. Hallie Preskill (author page)SAGE
  3. Hallie PreskillFSG
  4. Past award winnersAmerican Evaluation Association
  5. Building capacity for organizational learning through evaluative inquiryEvaluation 5(1) · 1999
  6. Evaluative Inquiry for Learning in OrganizationsWoodslane (SAGE distributor) · 1999
  7. Reframing Evaluation Through Appreciative InquirySAGE · 2006
  8. A multidisciplinary model of evaluation capacity buildingAmerican Journal of Evaluation, via ALNAP · 2008
  9. Building Evaluation Capacity: Activities for Teaching and Training, 2nd ed.SAGE · 2015
  10. Evaluating Social InnovationCenter for Evaluation Innovation · 2012
  11. Guide to Evaluating Collective ImpactFSG · 2014
  12. Appreciative inquiryBetterEvaluation
  13. Guide to Appreciative InquiryUNITAR · 2015
  14. Using Appreciative Inquiry in Evaluation: New Directions for Evaluation, Number 100 (listing)Hatchards · 2003
  15. Resonance, stickiness and the value propositions of evaluation capacity buildingNew Directions for Evaluation (Montclair State University copy) · 2021
  16. Communities of practice as an effective ECB approach for nonevaluation specialistsNew Directions for Evaluation (UTS repository) · 2024
  17. woodslane.com.auWeb page
Chapter 11 · 12 sources

Sanjeev Sridharan

  1. Sridharan, Sanjeev (alumni record)UC Irvine School of Social Ecology
  2. Rethinking the role of complexity in global health interventionsUCSF events calendar · 2019
  3. Sanjeev Sridharan, speakerAsian Evaluation Week, Asian Development Bank
  4. Understanding what evaluation is and why it matters (webinar)Pan American Health Organization · 2021
  5. American Journal of Evaluation 27(2), table of contentsSAGE · 2006
  6. Ten steps to making evaluation matterEvaluation and Program Planning (IDEAS/RePEc record) · 2011
  7. The Top 10 Questions: A Guide to Evaluating Place-Based InitiativesPolicy Horizons Canada · 2011
  8. Valuing and embracing complexityEvaluation and Program Planning (IDEAS/RePEc record) · 2020
  9. Learning from experiences of evaluators implementing theory-driven evaluations in diverse settingsEvaluation and Program Planning (IDEAS/RePEc record) · 2023
  10. From Silos to Ecologies: Towards an Ecology of Evidence to Navigate SolutionsRoutledge · 2026
  11. Towards a transformative view of evaluation (speaker series)Institute for Work and Health
  12. Ten steps to making evaluation matter (full text)Meghalaya Evaluation School (hosted PDF) · 2011
Chapter 12 · 15 sources

Patricia J. Rogers

  1. Patricia Rogers in conversationAustralian Evaluation Society blog · 2019
  2. Patricia RogersANZSOG
  3. Patricia RogersWorld Bank Independent Evaluation Group
  4. Patricia Rogers, speakerAsian Evaluation Week, ADB · 2023
  5. Using programme theory to evaluate complicated and complex aspects of interventionsEvaluation 14(1), via BetterEvaluation · 2008
  6. Purposeful Program Theory (listing)MandE NEWS · 2011
  7. AEA and BetterEvaluation partnershipAEA365 · 2013
  8. Better Evaluation RainbowThe Change Agency · 2015
  9. BetterEvaluation (history)BetterEvaluation
  10. Better EvaluationANZSOG legacy site
  11. Theory of Change: Methodological Briefs, Impact Evaluation No. 2UNICEF Office of Research (IDEAS/RePEc record) · 2014
  12. Footprint Evaluation (AEA365 post)AEA365 · 2022
  13. Purposeful Program Theory (sample chapter and contents)Jossey-Bass via e-bookshelf · 2011
  14. betterevaluation.orgWeb page
  15. eval.orgWeb page
Chapter 13 · 11 sources

Robert Chambers

  1. The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal (World Development 22(7))University of Hohenheim (reading copy of the Elsevier article) · 1994
  2. Interview with Robert Chambers (Development and Change)Erasmus University Repository · 2013
  3. Robert Chambers, Honorary FellowInternational Institute of Social Studies
  4. Robert Chambers author pagePractical Action Publishing
  5. Revolutionizing Development: Reflections on the Work of Robert ChambersInstitute of Development Studies · 2011
  6. IDS Bulletin: reflecting on 50 years of Robert Chambers' workInstitute of Development Studies
  7. From an article to a world view: a lifetime relationship with participationParticipatory Methods (IDS) · 2026
  8. Putting the Last First (book notes)Logan Cochrane, Thought Provokers
  9. Handbook on Community-Led Total SanitationSuSanA (Plan International UK and IDS) · 2008
  10. Rapid and participatory rural appraisal: notes on practical approaches and methodsIDS OpenDocs · 1990
  11. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
Chapter 14 · 13 sources

Egon G. Guba and Yvonna S. Lincoln

  1. Egon Guba obituaryHillier Funeral Home · 2008
  2. Guba, Egon G.SAGE Encyclopedia of Evaluation · 2005
  3. Lincoln, Yvonna S.SAGE Encyclopedia of Evaluation · 2005
  4. Yvonna S. Lincoln, author pageSAGE Publishing
  5. Criteria for Assessing Naturalistic Inquiries as Reports (ERIC ED297007), by Lincoln and GubaERIC via Internet Archive · 1988
  6. Guidelines and Checklist for Constructivist (a.k.a. Fourth Generation) Evaluation, by Guba and LincolnSAGE (study resources) · 2001
  7. TrustworthinessResearch Basics, University of Connecticut
  8. Fourth Generation Evaluation (publisher page)SAGE Publishing · 1989
  9. Toward a Methodology of Naturalistic Inquiry in Educational EvaluationCRESST, UCLA · 1978
  10. AEA365 post by Jennifer Greene on Guba and LincolnAmerican Evaluation Association
  11. Founders: Ohio StateThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University
  12. FoundersThe Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University
  13. eval.orgWeb page
Chapter 15 · 13 sources

Jennifer C. Greene

  1. Jennifer Caroline Greene profileUniversity of Illinois Experts
  2. Keynote speakers, Münster 2009DeGEval archive · 2009
  3. Theorists' Theories of Evaluation: A Conversation with Jennifer Greene (Tarsilla)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation · 2010
  4. Toward a Conceptual Framework for Mixed-Method Evaluation DesignsALNAP · 1989
  5. Advancing Mixed-Method EvaluationHarvard Family Research Project, The Evaluation Exchange
  6. Mixed Methods in Social Inquiry (author information and excerpt)Wiley / Jossey-Bass · 2007
  7. The SAGE Handbook of EvaluationSAGE Publishing · 2006
  8. Using a values-engaged educative evaluation approach (Tillman dissertation)University of Illinois IDEALS · 2015
  9. The Mystery of Mixing Methods (Vaessen)World Bank Independent Evaluation Group · 2017
  10. Lecture series brings renowned professor of education psychology to ASUASU News · 2010
  11. Disrupting Program Evaluation and Mixed Methods Research for a More Just SocietyUniversity of Illinois Experts · 2023
  12. Past Award Winners; Annual Conference HistoryAmerican Evaluation Association
  13. eval.orgWeb page
Chapter 16 · 11 sources

Rick Davies and Jess Dart

  1. The Most Significant Change (MSC) Technique: A Guide to Its UseDavies and Dart (copy hosted by UC Agriculture and Natural Resources) · 2005
  2. Most Significant Change (MSC) special issue pageMonitoring and Evaluation NEWS
  3. Order and Diversity: Representing and Assisting Organisational Learning in Non-Government Aid OrganisationsMonitoring and Evaluation NEWS · 1998
  4. Stories, Evaluation and Learning: Target 10 trial (PLA Notes 38)IIED, via BetterEvaluation · 2000
  5. A Dialogical, Story-Based Evaluation Tool: The Most Significant Change TechniqueALNAP library (American Journal of Evaluation) · 2003
  6. Rick Davies profileCEDIL
  7. Jess Dart speaker profileAustralian Evaluation Society conference · 2026
  8. Most significant change technique (chapter on dialogue methods)ANU Press
  9. Stories of Significance: Redefining ChangeMonitoring and Evaluation NEWS · 2007
  10. en.wikipedia.orgWeb page
  11. digitalarchive.worldfishcenter.orgWeb page
Chapter 17 · 12 sources

Donna M. Mertens

  1. Donna M. Mertens author pageSAGE Publishing
  2. Mertens, Donna M. (Encyclopedia of Evaluation entry)SAGE Knowledge · 2005
  3. Transformative Research and Evaluation (author and book details)Guilford Press · 2008
  4. Program Evaluation Theory and Practice, third edition (authors)Guilford Press · 2025
  5. Donna Mertens recognized for global impact with TEI's first Social Betterment AwardClaremont Graduate University · 2025
  6. Transformative Paradigm: Mixed Methods and Social JusticeJournal of Mixed Methods Research, via SAGE study site · 2007
  7. American Journal of Evaluation vol. 20 no. 1 contentsSAGE Journals · 1999
  8. Inclusiveness and Social Justice in Evaluation: A Conversation with Donna M. Mertens (Tarsilla)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation · 2010
  9. Indigenous Pathways into Social Research: Voices of a New GenerationMIT Press Bookstore (Left Coast Press listing) · 2013
  10. Avaliação Transformadora para mudanças transformadoras (keynote slides)ENAP Repository · 2026
  11. Research and Evaluation in Education and Psychology, sixth editionBokus (SAGE listing) · 2024
  12. Past Award Winners; Annual Conference HistoryAmerican Evaluation Association
Chapter 18 · 15 sources

Ray C. Rist

  1. Rist, Ray C. (Encyclopedia of Evaluation)SAGE · 2005
  2. Linking Evaluation Theory and Practice: Exploring Ray Rist's Enduring LegacyJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation · 2025
  3. Linking Evaluation Theory and Practice (full text)Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation · 2025
  4. Capacity Development in Evaluation: The Role of IPDETJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation (via ResearchGate) · 2025
  5. Ten Steps to a Results-Based Monitoring and Evaluation SystemWorld Bank · 2004
  6. Student Social Class and Teacher Expectations: The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy in Ghetto EducationHarvard Educational Review · 1970
  7. The Urban School: A Factory for Failure (catalogue record)National Institute for Educational Policy Research library · 1973
  8. Ray C. Rist author profileWorld Bank Open Knowledge Repository
  9. TrusteesHorowitz Foundation for Social Policy
  10. The Clash of the Counter-bureaucracy and DevelopmentCenter for Global Development · 2010
  11. IPDET: International Program for Development Evaluation TrainingIPDET · 2026
  12. IPDET Welcomes 171 Participants from 63 Countries to its 2023 On-Site Evaluation Training ProgramGlobal Evaluation Initiative · 2023
  13. The Capacity to Evaluate: Why Countries Need It (Capacity Development Briefs No. 17), Linda Morra-Imas and Ray C. RistWorld Bank Open Knowledge Repository · 2006
  14. gsdrc.orgWeb page
  15. openknowledge.worldbank.orgWeb page
Chapter 19 · 15 sources

Esther Duflo and Abhijit Banerjee

  1. Abhijit Banerjee: BiographicalNobelPrize.org · 2019
  2. Esther Duflo: BiographicalNobelPrize.org · 2019
  3. Press release: The Prize in Economic Sciences 2019NobelPrize.org · 2019
  4. Field Experiments and the Practice of Policy (Nobel lecture)NobelPrize.org · 2019
  5. Field Experiments and the Practice of Economics (Nobel lecture)NobelPrize.org · 2019
  6. About J-PALJ-PAL
  7. Balsakhi remedial tutoring in Vadodara and Mumbai, IndiaJ-PAL
  8. Improving Immunization Rates Through Regular Camps and Incentives in IndiaJ-PAL
  9. Duflo and Banerjee to Join UZHUniversity of Zurich · 2025
  10. Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about DevelopmentJournal of Economic Literature (author copy, Princeton) · 2010
  11. French academic becomes youngest ever winner of Nobel prize for economicsThe Local France · 2019
  12. Broadening the range of designs and methods for impact evaluationsGSDRC (DFID Working Paper 38) · 2012
  13. Using Randomization in Development Economics Research: A Toolkit (NBER Technical Working Paper 333)National Bureau of Economic Research · 2006
  14. Mainstreaming an Effective Intervention: Evidence from Randomized Evaluations of Teaching at the Right Level in India (NBER Working Paper 22746)EdTech Hub library record · 2016
  15. nobelprize.orgWeb page
Chapter 20 · 18 sources

Zenda Ofir

  1. Zenda Ofir (fellow profile)Robert Bosch Academy
  2. Zenda OfirClaremont Evaluation Center New York
  3. Zenda OfirBounce Beyond
  4. Zenda Ofir, Evaluation Reference GroupCGIAR Independent Advisory and Evaluation Service
  5. Zenda Ofir (professional profile)LinkedIn
  6. Made in Africa Evaluation 1. The beginningZenda Ofir, Tomorrow and Then blog · 2018
  7. Tomorrow and Then (blog home page)zendaofir.com
  8. CECAN seminar with Zenda OfirCECAN · 2018
  9. International Evaluation Academy week post (Ofir and Chaplowe)AEA365 · 2022
  10. 3 Horizons Evaluation InitiativeInternational Evaluation Academy · 2024
  11. Research Quality PlusIDRC
  12. Embedding evaluation theory on African philosophies: An asset to evaluation transformationAfrican Evaluation Journal 12(2) · 2024
  13. Research Quality Plus: a holistic approach to evaluating research (catalogue record)IDRC Digital Library · 2016
  14. Research Quality Plus: a holistic approach to evaluating researchIDRC · 2018
  15. A better measure of research from the global south (journal club summary of Lebel and McLean, Nature 2018)Research Impact Canada · 2018
  16. IDRC Research Quality Plus: A Holistic Approach to Evaluating ResearchOn Think Tanks · 2016
  17. Three horizons: a pathways practice for transformation (Sharpe, Hodgson, Leicester, Lyon and Fazey), Ecology and Society 21(2)University of Dundee Discovery · 2016
  18. evalpartners.orgWeb page
Chapter 21 · 15 sources

Howard White

  1. Professor Howard White (biography)World Health Organization
  2. Howard WhiteGlobal Development Network
  3. Howard White (profile)Guidelines International Network
  4. Howard White, presenter biographyKTDRR 2019 conference · 2019
  5. Theory-based impact evaluation: principles and practice (3ie Working Paper 3)3ie · 2009
  6. Q&A with Howard White, Head of New Impact Evaluation Entity, 3IECenter for Global Development
  7. When Will We Ever Learn? Closing the Evaluation GapCenter for Global Development · 2006
  8. 3ie Annual Report 20153ie · 2015
  9. 15 years of 3ie: reflecting on our contributions and the work ahead3ie · 2023
  10. The twenty-first century experimenting society: the four waves of the evidence revolutionPalgrave Communications (IDEAS/RePEc record) · 2019
  11. Guidance for producing a Campbell evidence and gap mapCampbell Systematic Reviews (PMC) · 2020
  12. Some reflections on current debates in impact evaluation3ie via ALNAP · 2009
  13. cedilprogramme.orgWeb page
  14. ideas.repec.orgWeb page
  15. gsdrc.orgWeb page
Chapter 22 · 13 sources

Bagele M. Chilisa

  1. Professor Chilisa appointed to UNDP Evaluation Advisory PanelUniversity of Botswana · 2018
  2. Mastercard Foundation funds Pan African Indigenous Evaluation Consortium projectUniversity of Botswana
  3. Decoloniality and indigenous methods in global health evaluationLondon School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine · 2024
  4. Indigenous Research Methodologies, second editionSAGE · 2019
  5. Review of Indigenous Research Methodologies (Van der Westhuizen)African Evaluation Journal · 2013
  6. Review of Indigenous Research Methodologies (Hanson)International Journal of Critical Indigenous Studies · 2012
  7. Decolonizing and Indigenizing Evaluation Practice in Africa: Toward African Relational Evaluation ApproachesCanadian Journal of Program Evaluation 30(3) · 2016
  8. Indigenous Made in Africa Evaluation Frameworks (Chilisa and Mertens)American Journal of Evaluation 42(2) · 2021
  9. Towards defining and advancing Made in Africa Evaluation (Omosa et al.)African Evaluation Journal 9(1) · 2021
  10. Embedding evaluation theory on African philosophies: An asset to evaluation transformationAfrican Evaluation Journal 12(2) · 2024
  11. Bagele ChilisaWikipedia
  12. Made in Africa Evaluation blog series, part 3SAMEA · 2017
  13. Research ethics principles (teaching slides citing Chilisa 2012 on the four Rs)National Centre for Research Methods
Chapter 23 · 15 sources

Marco Segone

  1. Marco Segone (speaker profile)Asian Evaluation Week, Asian Development Bank
  2. Peer Review Panel Members biographies 2020 to 2021UNEG · 2020
  3. Marco Segone (author profile)Academia.edu
  4. EvalPartners historyEvalPartners
  5. Previous co-chairsEvalPartners
  6. 2015 declared as International Year of EvaluationEvalPartners · 2013
  7. Building capacity for the evaluation of development activities at the country level, A/RES/69/237UN Digital Library · 2014
  8. From Policies to Results: Developing Capacities for Country Monitoring and Evaluation SystemsUNICEF · 2010
  9. How to design and manage equity-focused evaluationsALNAP (UNICEF publication) · 2011
  10. Eval4Action campaign concept noteEuropean Evaluation Society · 2020
  11. Annual report on the evaluation function 2020UNFPA · 2021
  12. Note verbale on recruitment of the Director, Independent Evaluation OfficeUNFPA, via SKNIS · 2026
  13. How to design and manage Equity-focused evaluations (download page)GIFE Sinapse · 2011
  14. eval.orgWeb page
  15. unfpa.orgWeb page
Chapter 24 · 9 sources

Sonal Zaveri

  1. Sonal Zaveri, Evaluation Reference GroupCGIAR Independent Advisory and Evaluation Service
  2. Q and A: Sonal Zaveri on the power and potential of real-time evaluationCGIAR · 2023
  3. Making Evaluation Matter: Writings from South AsiaIDRC and SAGE India · 2014
  4. TWG1 Newsletter no. 1 2022 (article on the UNICEF real-time gender evaluation)European Evaluation Society · 2022
  5. Practical Evaluation Capacity Development: Lessons from South AsiaGlobal Evaluation Week · 2022
  6. DECI final technical reportBetterEvaluation (IDRC project) · 2012
  7. GENSA: A Movement for Gender Equity in South AsiaSouthern Voice · 2025
  8. About Sonal Zaveri (author page)Southern Voice · 2025
  9. Making Evaluation Matter: Writings from South Asia (full text copy)Tamil Nadu Agricultural University (hosted PDF of the SAGE and IDRC edition) · 2014
NextAbout HubForgeThe people, knowledge and tools behind this book

About HubForge

Strengthening the world's evidence ecosystem

MonitoringEvaluationResearchLearning

The giants in this book did not work alone. Their ideas spread because people taught them, tested them, argued over them and passed them on. HubForge exists to keep that going.

HubForge Global Impact Network Foundation is a not-for-profit organisation founded in India in October 2025, with a global purpose: a home for everyone who works to generate and use evidence for social good.

Rigorous evidence. Open to all. Made with joy.

HubForge

People

Eval Corps volunteers support organisations, and hands-on mentorship opens the field to young and emerging evaluators.

Knowledge

Free playbooks, a consulting toolkit, this book, webinars, podcasts and a monthly digest of resources.

Products

Open platforms for evaluation strategy, sampling and creative learning, using AI where it helps people learn better.

Partnerships

Strategy, evaluation and MEL support for NGOs, foundations and public institutions, focused on learning.

Each part feeds the others. Volunteers learn by supporting real organisations, what they learn becomes open tools and resources, and income from services goes back into public goods for everyone.

Open tools, built for the field

The first yearAs of October 2026
68countries reached by EvalCanvas
336organisations on EvalCanvas
630+people using EvalCanvas
4free playbooks
10volunteers supporting 5 NGOs
3webinars
Join in

If this book has sparked something, there is a place for you: as a volunteer, a mentee, a partner or a supporter.

hubforgeglobal@gmail.com · www.hubforgeglobal.com
NextAbout the curatorAnd the HubForge playbooks
Portrait of Shashidhar S A

About the curator

Shashidhar S A

Founder, HubForge Global. Driving evaluation ecosystems through people, process and product.

MERL & AI innovatorEn-intrapreneurEcosystem builder
Connect on LinkedIn

Why this book

Shashidhar has long loved the lives, ideas, experiments and breakthrough moments of scientists, mathematicians and entrepreneurs: the stories behind original thinking, and the way those stories inspire people. He curated Giants of Evidence to bring that kind of story to monitoring, evaluation and learning, to celebrate the people who built the field, and to help a new generation ask better questions of its own.

An engineer by training, Shashidhar has spent about a decade in monitoring, evaluation and learning across India's social sector. His path runs through seven roles, from grassroots field work to state-level government partnerships and the design of MEL systems.

In the global evaluation community

An active volunteer, contributing to IOCE, the International Organization for Cooperation in Evaluation, and to Eval4Action, working alongside the EvalYouth Global Network.

Also from HubForge

This book shows where the field's ideas came from. The HubForge playbooks and toolkit show how to put them to work, free at playbooks.hubforgeglobal.com.

A note for the next reader

Was this useful?

Rate the playbook and, if you like, leave a short note about what worked.

Loading community features…

Your rating

An anonymous browser ID remembers your rating. You can update your rating from this browser.